AI in Action: A practical comparison of image description tools

This image presents feedback data showcasing the positive impact of a service, likely provided by an organization named Henshaws. Here’s a detailed description:

1. Header:

• The title emphasizes the importance of monitoring and understanding service impacts in real-time. It states that the feedback from those who have benefited from these services has been “overwhelmingly positive.”

2. Visual Breakdown:

• There are circular bar graphs in various colors corresponding to different metrics, each accompanied by descriptive text.

3. Categories and Metrics:

• Information(green):
• 90% of individuals report better access to information and support for their daily and future needs.
• This is a significant improvement from 7% before using the service.
• Support(yellow):
• 91% have established a strong support network, up from 38% pre-service.
• Wellbeing(pink):
• 84% reported an improvement in their emotional wellbeing.
• Confidence(blue):
• 83% now feel more independent and confident.

4. Image of a Person:

• On the left side, there is a photo of an older man sitting at a table with a thoughtful expression, holding a cup. His presence complements the narrative about support and emotional wellbeing.

5. Design Elements:

• Bright, engaging colors are used to represent each category (green, yellow, pink, and blue). Additional abstract shapes and patterns add vibrancy to the design.

This infographic effectively communicates how the organization’s services have positively influenced participants across key areas like information access, support networks, emotional wellbeing, and confidence.

This image captures a lively and cheerful scene in what appears to be a creative or recreational setting. Here’s a detailed description:

1. People:

• A woman is seated in the center, smiling warmly. She is wearing a tiger-themed hat with a playful expression, suggesting she is participating in an activity.
• A man sits to her side, interacting with a bright red puppet with long yellow hair, adding an element of fun and engagement.

2. Setting:

• The background includes colorful decorations, toys, and creative supplies, indicating a playful, possibly therapeutic or community-focused environment.
• A large wooden spinner with sections labeled “Pirate,” “Fairy,” and “Mermaid” suggests themed activities or games.
• Plastic bins filled with items such as colorful balls and craft materials are visible, hinting at hands-on activities.

3. Overall Atmosphere:

• The scene is vibrant, with a mix of playful colors and props that create a welcoming, inclusive environment.

• The image conveys a sense of joy, creativity, and interaction, possibly in a setting designed for group activities, therapy, or community engagement.he

The image is a feedback infographic highlighting the positive impacts of services provided by an organization. At the top, there is a bold heading that reads: “FEEDBACK: Our ability to monitor and understand the impacts of our services in real-time has been crucial. Feedback from those we’ve assisted has been overwhelmingly positive.”

To the right, there are four categories of feedback, each with a corresponding icon and color:

1. Information (green with a magnifying glass icon): 90% have better access to information and support for their daily and future needs, a significant rise from 7% pre-service.
2. Support (orange with a heart icon): 91% have established a robust support network, up from 38% before joining Henshaws.
3. Wellbeing (pink with a thumbs-up icon): 84% reported improved emotional wellbeing.
4. Confidence (blue with a star icon): 83% now feel more independent and confident.

To the left, there is a circular graph with colored arcs representing the percentages mentioned in each category. Below the graph, there is an image of an elderly man sitting at a table, resting his head on his hand, and holding a cup. He appears to be smiling slightly.

The image shows a cheerful scene with two people and a puppet. A woman is sitting on a chair, wearing a tiger hat and a striped orange and white sweater. She is smiling and looking towards the camera. Next to her is a red puppet with long yellow hair, wearing a black outfit with purple accents. A man is kneeling beside the puppet, holding it up. He is wearing glasses and a green shirt with a subtle pattern. In the background, there is a colorful wheel with sections labeled “Pirate,” “Fairy,” and “Mermaid,” along with various colorful items and toys, including a box of multicolored plastic balls and a bag featuring characters from the Toy Story movie. The setting appears to be a playful, creative environment, possibly a classroom or activity room.

Feedback infographic highlights the positive impacts of a service provided by Henshaws:

– Information: 90% of people have better access to information and support for their daily and future needs, up from 7% pre-service.

– Support: 91% have established a robust support network, an increase from 38% before joining Henshaws.

– Wellbeing: 84% reported improved emotional wellbeing.

– Confidence: 83% now feel more independent and confident.

The infographic includes a visual representation of these statistics with colored arcs and icons corresponding to each category. There is also an image of a person sitting at a table with a cup in front of them, smiling and resting their head on their hand.

A woman wearing a tiger hat is sitting in a chair, smiling. Next to her, a man is holding a red puppet with long blonde hair. The room is filled with colorful items, including a container of multicolored balls, a spinning wheel with sections labeled “Pirate,” “Fairy,” and “Mermaid,” and various toys and decorations. The atmosphere appears playful and lively, suggesting a fun or creative environment.

The image features a person sitting at a table with a blurred face, holding a cup. In front of them is a pen. To the right, there is a graphic with concentric circles and text detailing feedback statistics:

– **Information**: 90% have better access to information and support, up from 7% pre-service.

– **Support**: 91% have established a robust support network, up from 38% before joining Henshaws.

– **Wellbeing**: 84% reported improved emotional wellbeing.

– **Confidence**: 83% now feel more independent and confident.

The text at the top emphasizes the importance of real-time monitoring and understanding of service impacts, noting overwhelmingly positive feedback.

The image shows a room with various objects and two people. One person is sitting on a chair wearing a striped shirt and a tiger hat. Next to them is a red puppet with yellow hair. The other person is kneeling or sitting on the floor, interacting with the puppet.

In the background, there is a colorful wheel with sections labeled “Pirate,” “Fairy,” and “Mermaid.” A table nearby holds a clear container filled with colorful plastic balls, a bottle of water, and other items. A large bag with a character design is also visible. The setting appears to be a room with wooden cabinets and a piano.

ChatGPT

The image contains a mix of text, graphics, and a photo. On the left side, there’s a photo of an older man sitting at a table, holding a cup with a slight smile and his head resting on one hand.

Next to the man, there are colorful concentric circles aligned with a set of labeled percentages on the right. These circles and labels represent feedback in various categories:

1. **Information (Green):**
– 90% have better access to information and support for daily and future needs, a rise from 7% pre-service.

2. **Support (Yellow):**
– 91% have established a robust support network, up from 38% before joining Henshaws.

3. **Wellbeing (Pink):**
– 84% reported improved emotional wellbeing.

4. **Confidence (Blue):**
– 83% now feel more independent and confident.

At the top, there’s a heading in bold: “FEEDBACK: Our ability to monitor and understand the impacts of our services in real-time has been crucial. Feedback from those we’ve assisted has been overwhelmingly positive.”

The graphics next to each category use icons to symbolize the type of feedback, like a speech bubble, thumbs up, and a star. There’s a colorful abstract design in the bottom right corner as well.

Claude

This image shows a feedback infographic about the impact of services provided by an organization called Henshaws. The data is presented in a circular graph format with different colored arcs, alongside a photo of a man sitting at a table with a cup, resting his head on his hand.

The feedback highlights four key areas of improvement:

1. Information (Green icon with magnifying glass):
– 90% have better access to information and support
– This shows a significant increase from 7% pre-service

2. Support (Yellow/orange icon with heart):
– 91% have established a robust support network
– Up from 38% before joining Henshaws

3. Wellbeing (Pink icon with thumbs up):
– 84% reported improved emotional wellbeing

4. Confidence (Blue icon with star):
– 83% now feel more independent and confident

The data is presented with colorful circular arcs corresponding to each metric, and includes icons and explanatory text for each category. The bottom right corner features a decorative design element with colored circles and curved lines.

The title emphasizes that their ability to monitor and understand the impacts of their services in real-time has been crucial, with overwhelmingly positive feedback from those they’ve assisted.

ChatGPT

The image shows a woman sitting in a chair wearing a tiger hat. She is smiling and holding a puppet with red skin and long blonde hair. A man is kneeling in front of her, interacting with the puppet. He is wearing glasses and a green shirt.

In the background, there are various colorful elements: a spinning wheel with words like “Pirate” and “Fairy” written on it, and several boxes filled with colorful balls and other items. There’s also a table with bottles and a small bag. The setting appears to be a playful, creative environment, possibly a classroom or activity room.

Claude

This image appears to be taken in what looks like a classroom or activity room setting. In the scene, there’s a person wearing a coral/salmon colored striped shirt and jeans, sitting in a striped chair, wearing what appears to be a novelty tiger hat. Next to them is another person in a teal/green shirt operating a red puppet with yellow hair. The puppet appears to be in the style of a Muppet or similar children’s puppet character.

In the background, there are several colorful elements including what appears to be a decorative wheel with different colored sections (possibly for games or activities), and containers of colorful plastic balls. The walls appear to be wooden or wood-paneled, and there are some children’s artwork or decorations visible on the walls.

The setting suggests this might be during a children’s educational or entertainment program, with props and materials scattered around that would be used for such activities.

There’s no denying that AI has revolutionised independent access to visual information for people with sight loss. However, it’s important to remember that AI isn’t perfect and can sometimes misinterpret aspects of an image. In some cases, AI can even ‘hallucinate,’ mistakenly identifying something that isn’t actually present.

Because of this, we don’t recommend relying solely on AI if you need a completely accurate description. For situations where precision is key, we suggest asking for a description from another person or making sure the image provider ensures the content is accessible.

AI can be a helpful tool, but it’s always best to combine it with other resources to ensure the most accurate and reliable results.

AI can describe the elements within an image, but often struggles to understand the full context, unless it’s explicitly clear.

For example, if you come across a picture of a famous person on social media and want to know who it is, AI can describe their appearance but may not be able to identify them specifically, unless their name is clearly visible in the image. Similarly, if you’re looking through holiday photos on your phone, AI can describe the people and objects in the picture, but won’t be able to tell you exactly where it was taken.

This highlights the importance of adding alt text to images. Alt text can provide the essential context that AI tools often miss, making visual content more meaningful and accessible.

When using an AI tool to describe an image, it involves uploading the image to an external system for analysis. This raises potential privacy concerns, as some AI tools store images and their analyses to further train their systems.

If privacy is a priority for you, we recommend avoiding uploading images that contain personal or sensitive information. Most AI tools include a privacy policy that outlines how your data will be stored and handled. Taking a moment to review these policies can help you make informed decisions about how and when to use these tools.

As mentioned earlier, AI is trained using vast datasets. However, these datasets don’t include everything, which can lead to biases and raise ethical concerns. For instance, when analysing images of people, AI may make assumptions about a person’s gender based on stereotypes. It might also miss important details, such as not recognising an item of clothing with cultural significance, or misinterpret a facial expression, leading to incorrect assumptions about someone’s emotions.

These limitations highlight the importance of using AI tools with a critical eye and understanding that they may not always provide a complete or accurate interpretation.